mimi.co.ke

Mimi Company of Kenya

All stories

Mimi ni Joel... My ex showed up on my wedding morning with a box of letters.

I thought I had closed that chapter. One knock made me question whether I had actually read it properly.

The story

I was getting married at 10 a.m. The suit was ready, my friends were downstairs and my phone would not stop ringing. At 7:15, someone knocked on the apartment door.

It was Natalie, my ex. We had dated for four years and broken up three years earlier. She was holding a small cardboard box.

She said she had found old letters while moving and wanted to return them before I got married. I asked why she had come in person. She said she did not want to post something so personal.

I should have taken the box and closed the door. Instead, I opened it. The letters were from our final year together. I had written some of them. She had kept all of them.

At the bottom was a photograph of us on a trip we had taken before things became difficult. I remembered that weekend. I also remembered how lonely I had felt during the months before we separated.

Natalie said she was happy for me. Then she asked whether I had ever wondered what would have happened if we had met at a different time.

I told her I was getting married in a few hours. She nodded and left.

I did not tell my fiancée immediately. I put the box in the car and went to the ceremony. During the vows, I kept thinking about the question.

After the wedding, my wife found the box while unpacking. She asked why I had hidden it. I said I had not known how to explain. She asked whether I still loved Natalie.

I said no, but the hesitation before the answer did more damage than the answer itself.

Now my wife thinks I married her while keeping a door open. I think I was surprised by the past and handled it badly. I cannot tell whether Natalie's visit was closure or an invitation, but I know I should have been honest.

The storyteller's moment of clarity
A closer look at the psychology
Next storyMimi ni Faith... My boyfriend moved into my apartment and slowly started acting like the landlord. ↗← Back to all stories

This record is generated by Mimi A.I., an instrument of Mimi Company of Kenya (mimi.co.ke). Any resemblance to actual persons, living or ghosted, or real-world events in Nairobi or beyond is strictly coincidental. While due diligence has been observed in compiling this file, Mimi Company of Kenya (mimi.co.ke) and its A.I. (ai.mimi.co.ke) accept no liability for emotional damage, group-chat fallout, or decisions made after reading.